There is nothing wrong with showing loyalty to the current coach. After all, it sounds like this coach has been very helpful to your DD. That said, what you are stating in this post is very troubling to me. He is taking anyone and everyone to try to fill the team and still doesn't have enough. I would suggest taking her to the workouts for the other team and see what happens. You shouldn't be expected to make an immediate decision, but a couple of workouts can buy you (and the current coach) some time, while getting to see what the new team has to offer.
NOTE: If there was a team last year, and he is having trouble filling the team this year, I would wonder why? Did some players age up? Or is there another reason that you are not aware of? Something else to consider...
NOTE: If there was a team last year, and he is having trouble filling the team this year, I would wonder why? Did some players age up? Or is there another reason that you are not aware of? Something else to consider...
I'm concerned he cannot field a full team. At the 3 tryouts only 2 girls have showed up at each tryout and he has taken every single one regardless of talent just to try to field a team. I told the new coach that DD had committed to another team and explained the situation. He said, just have her come out and let's go from there. Not sure how long he will wait. He is planning to play next weekend and needs another pitcher. I would hate to break a commitment and possibly burn a bridge.