how would you score this?

[smddad]

Base hit

Error is always on the throw, unless it's right in the bread box

 

[CoogansBluff]

Play 1: If the 3rd baseman is a stud playing 3rd its an error if she isn't I give her a hit

Scoring might change based how good the league is, but not based on how good a particular third baseman is. Otherwise, you'd hear things like, ''Fielding average of .912 would be higher if player were not such a stud.''