Here's the scenario: runner on 1st, ground ball to 2nd she flips to short for the force out, SS throws to 1st for double play. Ball is thrown into the dugout. Base ump calls the girl out and 2nd (correct call) and awards the runner going to 1st 2nd base because the ball left the field of play. The home plate ump walks out to base ump and they have a discussion. The home plate ump awards the base runner 3rd. His judgement was that she was through 1st base when the ball left the SS hand. Now the location of the runner at the time of the throw is a judgement call and i am not going to argue that. My question if the runner is past 1st base when that throw is made do they have to make an attempt to go to 2nd base to be awarded 3rd base?