Actually didn't think that was unreasonable at all.I agree and I have an unreasonable dislike of first baseman's gloves in softball. Players drop too many balls at the younger ages trying to figure it out.
It's probably just me but I wish they would just use their regular gloves.
I played 1B in baseball so I get it, but damn. 2B is covering 1B a lot of the time anyways (with a regular glove).
Unreasonable rant over...
Luv catching with my Fielding glove. I'm a defensive player with the added pleasure of framing.
Some first base & Catching mitt's have awkwardly small pockets. Dont grasp well. To much padding.